The First Ponderosa Thanksgiving (by BettyHT)

Summary: The celebration is held in the true spirit of the holiday as proclaimed by President Lincoln, but there is melancholy too.
Rating: PG  Word count: 1,692


The First Ponderosa Thanksgiving

Hoss was very curious as he watched his father read, stare into space, and then read again.

“Pa, what are you finding so interesting in the Territorial Enterprise? You read a bit and then you stare off into the fireplace. Must be something pretty big, huh?”

“Hoss, it is pretty big. They’ve printed a letter that President Lincoln has proclaimed. Listen to this: ‘The year that is drawing towards its close, has been filled with the blessings of fruitful fields and healthful skies. To these bounties, which are so constantly enjoyed that we are prone to forget the source from which they come, others have been added, which are of so extraordinary a nature, that they cannot fail to penetrate and soften even the heart which is habitually insensible to the ever watchful providence of Almighty God.‘ I’ve been staring into the fireplace wondering how we could thank the Lord for all the bounty we have received. I’m thinking we should invite all of our neighbors to a big thanksgiving kind of celebration. We could have roasted beef, and lots of potatoes. We could ask Hop Sing to make some of those delicious noodles, and perhaps some squash pie and apple pie.”

“Now you’re talking my language. I didn’t rightly understand exactly what the President was saying, but I understood you perfect like.” Hoss leaned back in the chair with a big smile. A good party with good food and good friends seemed like a great idea to him.

“Could we have fireworks, Pa? It’s not a real party without fireworks.”

Joe liked any kind of party especially if there was excitement and if there were a lot of pretty girls in attendance, he liked it even more. Just the thought of fireworks and girls at the same event had him grinning.

“No, Joseph, we will not have fireworks. This is supposed to be a giving of thanks.”

“Well, Pa, I know I’d be more thankful if there were fireworks.”

Hoss chuckled and Ben couldn’t stay serious either. Adam was serious though making Hoss wonder why.

“Now Adam, what are you reading over there? We’re trying to plan a party here.” Hoss was watching Adam who was reading the newspaper that their father had set aside.

“Hoss, I was reading the same article that Pa was reading. The ending is very meaningful not only in regards to the war in the east, but here too. He says that we should ‘fervently implore the interposition of the Almighty Hand to heal the wounds of the nation and to restore it as soon as may be consistent with the Divine purposes to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquility and Union.’ I’m thinking that if we accept the meaning of the whole letter, we should invite all of our neighbors.”

“Son, I did say we would invite all of our neighbors.”

“Pa, did you mean to include the Paiute neighbors too?”

Ben set his paper aside and looked at his eldest son with a look that said he was being tolerant but wasn’t going to be pushed into anything he thought was out of line.

“Adam, I don’t think the Paiute would be comfortable at a party here.”

Hoss disagreed with his father though as he got the point Adam was trying to make.

“Pa, I think Adam is right. We oughta invite ’em. We could have the party outside so they would be more at ease, and we could include some food that they would like. I know they’ll like the beef, but we could serve beans and berries and stuff like that too.”

Even Joe started to get into the spirit of it then.

“Hey, Pa, I like what my brothers are saying. It could be just like what those Pilgrims did. Maybe the Paiute would like to bring some of their food to the dinner too. We could ask everyone who’s coming to bring their favorite foods. We could play games like the Paiute do at their celebrations. We could have races, and shooting, and wrestling.”

Surprised but actually quite pleased to have his sons in agreement on something so significant, Ben was inclined to hear them out. He responded in a more reasonable tone after Joe finished what he had to say and smiled in Adam’s direction to let him know that he was reconsidering his eldest son’s initial proposal. “So you’re all in agreement that the Paiute should be invited?”

“Yes, Pa, I think we are.” Adam answered as Hoss and Joe nodded in agreement.

Pausing to try to think of everything that might go wrong, Ben agreed.

“All right, then, Joe you are in charge of organizing the games and having some prizes that would be acceptable whether a white or a Paiute wins. Hoss, I want you to work with Hop Sing in organizing how we are going to set up this meal outdoors and to make sure as Joe does that both white and Paiute will be happy with what is offered. Adam, I’ll go visit our white neighbors to invite them, and you can ride to the Paiute camp to invite them. I suppose this could be an annual celebration if all works out well.”

With all the work and preparations, the party was a success. There were some whites who wouldn’t attend when they found out that the Paiute would be there. There were some Paiute who refused to attend any celebration at a white man’s home because they thought of all white men as thieves who had stolen their land and suspected there would be more treachery. But there were plenty from both sides who thought a party before the winter set in was a wonderful idea. The more adventurous party guests were able to sample the foods of many other cultures finding many that they liked as Hop Sing had not only provided meals with a white and Paiute flavor but some of his Chinese dishes too. At the end of the party, Ben walked to stand by Chief Winnemucca as guests were leaving.

“I thank you for gracing my home with your presence. I hope that we can have this party of thanksgiving, friendship, and goodwill every year.”

“Sadly, my friend, I do not think that will happen. Maybe for a few years it will be so, but our people grow smaller in number every year as the trees we need for food are cut. The animals need them too and many of the animals are killed as well and the waters are made dirty by the mining. The sicknesses of the white man kill some of my people each year as well. They get the spots, and they get the fevers. Women become ill and have babies whose hearts do not beat for long. The old ones and the young ones die quickly from the sicknesses that we cannot fight. We grow weaker each year with enemies we can see and those we cannot. Soon we will be as the wind in the hills and the sand in the desert. But I thank you for giving us a time of peace and a time to thank our Great Spirit so he will welcome us home when it is time.”

With that, Winnemucca turned, raised his arm, and led the Paiute who filed out of the party to travel back to their home that would not be their home much longer. It was a party of thanksgiving and to promote healing, but there was only so much one party could do to change the hearts of men. Ben stood with his sons as they watched their friends leave. They were thankful for the time they had with them, but they were sad because they knew the years for that were short, and that would not change because too many of their white neighbors thought it was for the best.

The next morning, Hoss was excited to see what was on the table for breakfast. With all the leftovers from the celebration, Hop Sing didn’t have to cook to provide a feast for Hoss to appreciate.

“Oh, boy, we got pork, chicken, potatoes, pie, biscuits, and more. I really like that kind of party. We should have one like that more often.”

“Hoss, we had our good friends here for a purpose not just to have great food. Weren’t we trying to honor what the President meant when he asked us to pray for the restoration of peace, harmony, tranquility, and union on Thanksgiving?”

“Dadburnit, it is what we done, Pa, but I can hardly think with all this sitting in front of me. Now, where is Adam anyway? How come he ain’t here to help us clean up the leftovers?”

“He took it to heart, Hoss, and left this morning to bring some of the leftovers and a few cattle to the Paiute camp. With winter coming on, they could really use the food, and it might help with those who wouldn’t come to the party because they don’t even trust us because we’re white too.”

“I sure hope it helps. Sometimes I think in a hundred years or maybe more, folks will still be judging people by the color of their skin and what language they speak.”

Ever the optimist, Joe disagreed.

“Hoss, Americans have made so much progress just since the Constitution and Bill of Rights was put in place which was less than a hundred years ago. You can bet that in another hundred years, people will believe in real equality and treat everyone with respect.”

Having studied history as much as his eldest son, Ben wasn’t so sure that could happen.

“I would like to believe that could be true, Joe. I’m afraid though that it is easier to spread hate than love and easier to be greedy and selfish rather than to share and help so I have to take Hoss’ side in this one.”

“We’ll never know then, will we? It will be us to our descendants to know. I hope they do better than you and Hoss think they will.”

Loading

Author: BettyHT

I watched Bonanza when it first aired. In 2012, I discovered Bonanza fan fiction, and started writing stories as a fun hobby.

18 thoughts on “The First Ponderosa Thanksgiving (by BettyHT)

  1. In many ways, the world hasn’t moved on very far from the prejudices in this story. If only the morals and beliefs of our beloved Cartwrights were held by more folk. A thought provoking story Betty. Thanks and happy thanksgiving to all ❤️

    1. Thank you so much! We often think we have moved forward only to be reminded that we have made only small progress in some ways. But we have to keep trying even if it isn’t easy.

  2. A timeless reminder to offer gratitude for the many blessings in life, but to also seek to bring healing to the difficult times. A lovely story for this Thanksgiving Day.

    1. Thank you so much. It is a wonderful blessing on this holiday to have wonderful friends like you.

    1. Thank you so much. Yes, wouldn’t it be so much better if we could all be better to each other around the world and make it the wonderful world it could be?

  3. Lovely sentiments expressed in this story and I really wish lessons had been learned from what went before, but things are still not equal, in many places in the world
    Happy Thanksgiving to you all
    Little Joe forever

    1. Thank you so much. You are so right, and the holiday would be so much more enjoyable if your wish could only come true as Little Joe had so hoped it would.

  4. Powerful lessons represented here in this story that we all could learn. Not exactly the feel-good story I needed for Thanksgiving, but it was a good read anyway.

    1. Sorry that it wasn’t the warm fuzzy story you were expecting, but my history background tends to get in the way of that kind of story at this time of year. Thank you for reading.

    1. Thank you so much. It is a wonderful blessing on this holiday to have wonderful readers like you.

  5. Toujours le cœur sur la main et remplies de bonnes intentions, la famille Cartwright.
    Un Thanksgiving dans l’air du temps, mais la planète est malheureusement bien divisée.
    Ils ne sont plus là pour le voir. Surtout Adam/Pernell qui parlait de paix . . .

    1. Les Cartwrights voulaient bien mais leur invité Paiute a dit la vérité, et malheureusement l’optimisme de Joe était trop grand. Une grande partie de ce qu’ils espéraient changer n’a toujours pas changé.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.